Insurance agencies

AI for insurance agents: work every quote lead

Start your 7-day free trial

300 credits across all three Engines. No card required. Plans from $197/month.

By Nick Perry, Founder & CEOUpdated
The short answer

Jessica calls new quote leads within minutes, texts and emails them, asks your qualifying questions (line of insurance, current carrier, renewal date) and books the appointment with a licensed agent. Your agents quote and bind. Plans start at $197/month after a 7-day free trial with no card.

Insurance leads are a race. A shopper who fills out a quote form for auto, home, life, health or Medicare coverage is usually comparing several agencies at the same time. Shared leads go to more than one agent the moment they're sold. The agent who reaches the shopper first, and keeps following up, writes most of the policies.

The Engine gives insurance agencies an AI sales assistant built for that race. Jessica, our AI voice agent, calls, texts and emails new quote leads, qualifies them against your rules, follows up and books appointments with your licensed agents. She also answers inbound calls on your agency's own number 24/7.

Speed is the whole game

HawkSoft ran a mystery-shop test on insurance agencies by sending a fake lead and timing the responses. Only about 6% of agencies responded within five minutes. The best-performing agencies responded in about 3 minutes and made 5 to 10 contacts within 48 hours. Of the responses HawkSoft got, 60% were phone calls, 38% were emails and only 2% were texts.

That lines up with broader research. Harvard Business Review's 2011 study of 1.25 million leads found that contacting a lead within an hour made it nearly 7 times as likely to qualify as waiting even one more hour.

The takeaway for an agency: most of your competitors are slow, and almost none of them text. A fast, persistent, multi-channel follow-up process is one of the easiest ways to stand out. See how speed to lead works in Sales Engine.

What Jessica does for an insurance agency

Jessica is the AI voice agent in The Engine's Sales Engine. For an agency, she:

Jessica doesn't sell or bind policies, give coverage advice or quote rates. Your licensed agents do that. She gets the right shoppers onto their calendars.

Sales Engine automation settings: kill switch, meeting reminders and booking texts, text before the first call, text after a dropped call, last text of the day and CRM lead sync.
Sales Engine automation settings: kill switch, meeting reminders and booking texts, text before the first call, text after a dropped call, last text of the day and CRM lead sync.
Sales Engine Activity History: calls, texts and emails logged per lead, with direction, status, who ended the call, duration and time. Lead details blurred.
Sales Engine Activity History: calls, texts and emails logged per lead, with direction, status, who ended the call, duration and time. Lead details blurred.

Built for how agencies buy leads

Exclusive and shared internet leads. Speed matters most here. Jessica's first touch goes out right away, and the follow-up doesn't stop after one voicemail.

Inbound calls. When shoppers reach your number after hours or during a busy hour, Jessica answers, qualifies and books instead of sending them to voicemail.

Aged leads. Most agencies have thousands of old quotes in their CRM or agency management system. With the right consent in place, The Engine can run lead reactivation campaigns timed around renewal dates, and Jessica books the shoppers who reply.

Captive and independent agencies, MGAs and call floors. The workflow is the same whether you have 2 producers or 50: every lead gets a fast first touch, a written cadence and a booked appointment when they're ready.

Consent and compliance come first

Insurance is one of the most heavily regulated industries for phone and text marketing. In February 2024, the FCC confirmed that AI-generated voices count as "artificial" voices under the TCPA, so outbound AI calls generally require the called party's prior consent, and telemarketing calls need prior express written consent. Before you turn on any automated follow-up:

This isn't legal advice. The Engine follows the campaign, qualification rules and cadence you set, so set them with compliance in mind.

Playbook: a purchased auto-quote lead

Step What happens Who handles it
1. Lead arrives Shared or exclusive quote lead lands in your CRM, with consent captured —
2. First contact Jessica calls within minutes. No answer: a text and an email right after Jessica
3. Qualify Current carrier, renewal date, vehicles and drivers, other lines to bundle Jessica, using your questions
4. Book Books a quote call with a licensed agent Jessica
5. No answer Keeps following up on your cadence until the lead books or opts out Jessica
6. Quote and bind Coverage advice, quoting, binding Your licensed agent

One system for content, campaigns and follow-up

The Engine is an AI revenue workforce with three engines:

The Engine connects to GoHighLevel, HubSpot, Salesforce, Zoho, Podio, Slack, Claude and ChatGPT, plus MCP, APIs and webhooks for custom integrations.

How it compares

Enterprise conversational AI tools such as Conversica are sold through demos and annual contracts and focus on email, text and chat conversations. Generic AI receptionists answer the phone but usually don't chase leads that don't book. The Engine is built for agencies that need every lead called, texted and emailed, then booked, at a monthly price a small agency can test. See our fair, sourced comparison of The Engine vs Conversica.

Pricing

Every plan includes Content Engine, Marketing Engine and Sales Engine (Jessica), plus 24/7 human support. Plans differ in monthly credits and phone numbers:

Plan Price Credits Phone numbers
Basic $197/mo 1,600 1
Growth $397/mo 3,500 2
Scale $697/mo 7,000 3
Enterprise Custom Custom Custom

Start with a 7-day free trial: 300 credits, no card required, and nothing is charged automatically when the trial ends. See pricing.

Start your free trial and run this week's quote leads through Jessica.

Frequently asked questions

What can AI do for insurance agents?

The Engine's Sales Engine uses Jessica, an AI voice agent, to call, text and email new quote leads, qualify them against your rules, follow up and book appointments with your licensed agents. She also answers inbound calls on your agency's own number 24/7.

Does Jessica quote or sell policies?

No. Jessica qualifies leads and books appointments. Your licensed agents give coverage advice, quote rates and bind policies.

How fast should an insurance agency respond to a new lead?

As fast as possible. In HawkSoft's mystery-shop test, only about 6% of agencies responded within five minutes, and the top performers responded in about 3 minutes and made 5 to 10 contacts within 48 hours.

Is AI calling legal for insurance leads?

The TCPA applies. The FCC confirmed in 2024 that AI-generated voices count as artificial voices, so outbound AI calls generally need prior consent, and telemarketing calls need prior express written consent. Have your compliance team review your consent language. This isn't legal advice.

Can The Engine work my aged leads?

Yes, with the right consent in place. The Engine can run lead reactivation campaigns, and Jessica books the shoppers who reply.

What does it cost?

Plans start at $197/month (Basic, 1,600 credits, 1 phone number). Growth is $397/month and Scale is $697/month. Enterprise is custom. Every plan starts with a 7-day free trial with 300 credits and no card required.

Put The Engine to work this week

Start your 7-day free trial: 300 credits across all three Engines, no card required. Nothing is charged automatically when the trial ends.

Related

Sources

  1. HawkSoft, Speed 2 Lead insurance lead response case study: https://blog.hawksoft.com/speed-2-lead-case-study
  2. Oldroyd, McElheran and Elkington, The Short Life of Online Sales Leads, Harvard Business Review, March 2011: https://hbr.org/2011/03/the-short-life-of-online-sales-leads
  3. FCC Declaratory Ruling on AI-generated voices under the TCPA, Feb 2024: https://www.fcc.gov/document/fcc-confirms-tcpa-applies-ai-technologies-generate-human-voices